HC: Ill-treated parents can take back son’s assets
Shibu.Thomas@timesgroup.com
Mumbai: 16.07.2018
Elderly parents can take back a share in their property given to a son as a gift if he fails to look after them or harasses them, the Bombay high court has ruled.
Citing the special law for the maintenance of senior citizens, a division bench of justices Ranjit More and Anuja Prabhudesai upheld a tribunal’s order that had cancelled a gift deed given by an Andheri resident by which he had granted 50% share in his flat to his son. “The gift deed was made at the request of the son and his wife. It is implied that the elderly father as well his second wife would be looked after by them after transfer of 50% share in the flat,” said the judges. “The son and his wife were willing to look after the father, but were unwilling to do so in respect of the second wife,” the court said.
Maintenance Act has provisions to protect elderly
The court said, “In the above circumstances, we do not find any error in the order (cancelling the gift deed), therefore, we are not inclined to entertain this petition.” It then dismissed the petition filed by the son.
The Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 has provisions that protect parents and elderly persons who have signed away their property or assets to a person so that they would be taken care of, but are then left destitute. If a senior citizen has signed an agreement after 2007 to transfer his or her share in the property, for example through a gift deed on the condition that their basic needs would be taken care of, but the person refuses to honour the agreement, then a maintenance tribunal is empowered to quash the agreement.
In the present case, the senior citizen’s first wife died in 2014. Last year, when he wanted to remarry, his son and daughter-in-law requested that a share of the Andheri flat should be transferred to them. To buy peace in the family, he transferred 50% share in the flat to his son in May 2014. Subsequently, the son and daughterin-law started insulting the elderly man’s second wife. According to the father, he and his second wife were forced to leave the Andheri flat and reside in another apartment on rent. The father then approached the maintenance tribunal, which cancelled the gift deed.
The son challenged the tribunal’s order. He said that he was willing to allow his father to stay in the flat, but would not permit his stepmother. The HC dismissed the petition pointing to the provisions of the law.
Shibu.Thomas@timesgroup.com
Mumbai: 16.07.2018
Elderly parents can take back a share in their property given to a son as a gift if he fails to look after them or harasses them, the Bombay high court has ruled.
Citing the special law for the maintenance of senior citizens, a division bench of justices Ranjit More and Anuja Prabhudesai upheld a tribunal’s order that had cancelled a gift deed given by an Andheri resident by which he had granted 50% share in his flat to his son. “The gift deed was made at the request of the son and his wife. It is implied that the elderly father as well his second wife would be looked after by them after transfer of 50% share in the flat,” said the judges. “The son and his wife were willing to look after the father, but were unwilling to do so in respect of the second wife,” the court said.
Maintenance Act has provisions to protect elderly
The court said, “In the above circumstances, we do not find any error in the order (cancelling the gift deed), therefore, we are not inclined to entertain this petition.” It then dismissed the petition filed by the son.
The Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 has provisions that protect parents and elderly persons who have signed away their property or assets to a person so that they would be taken care of, but are then left destitute. If a senior citizen has signed an agreement after 2007 to transfer his or her share in the property, for example through a gift deed on the condition that their basic needs would be taken care of, but the person refuses to honour the agreement, then a maintenance tribunal is empowered to quash the agreement.
In the present case, the senior citizen’s first wife died in 2014. Last year, when he wanted to remarry, his son and daughter-in-law requested that a share of the Andheri flat should be transferred to them. To buy peace in the family, he transferred 50% share in the flat to his son in May 2014. Subsequently, the son and daughterin-law started insulting the elderly man’s second wife. According to the father, he and his second wife were forced to leave the Andheri flat and reside in another apartment on rent. The father then approached the maintenance tribunal, which cancelled the gift deed.
The son challenged the tribunal’s order. He said that he was willing to allow his father to stay in the flat, but would not permit his stepmother. The HC dismissed the petition pointing to the provisions of the law.
No comments:
Post a Comment