Officials use corona to mask RTI queries

 Officials use corona to mask RTI queries

Govt Bodies Cite Sec 4 of Epidemic Diseases Act To Decline Information

---

Meghdoot.Sharon@timesgroup.com

Ahmedabad:

03.01.2022

What is cost incurred on treating patients at designated private Covid-19 hospitals in Ahmedabad? What is sanctioned strength, and vacancies of doctors and nurses at the Civil hospital in Ahmedabad? What are the names of persons whom SVP hospital has administered Remdesivir injections? How many Covid-19 deaths have taken place at AMC-run hospitals?

In all the above instances, information was not provided to applicants who filed queries under Right to Information (RTI) Act citing confidentiality clause as the Epidemic Diseases Act, 1897 is in force. Ever since the outbreak of Covid-19 almost two years ago, public authorities, especially those in the health sector, have been denying information by citing section 4 of the Epidemic Diseases Act, 1897, allege activists.

RTI activist Alpesh Bhavsar says earlier this year he sought information on patients treated by private designated Covid-19 hospitals and the expenses incurred. Six of the seven Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation (AMC) zones said information was confidential under the Epidemic Diseases Act, 1897, one zone provided it.

“The authorities cite section 4 of the Epidemic Diseases Act, but all we are seeking is information. There is no intention of initiating legal proceedings. When we appeal, authorities are then forced to provide information,” he said.

Section 4 of the said act has no mention of not providing information. It in fact grants protection to persons against legal proceedings for anything done in good faith, say activists. Section 4 of the Epidemic Diseases Act, 1897 reads – “Protection to persons acting under Act. No suit or other legal proceeding shall lie against any person for anything done or in good faith intended to be done under this Act. ”

In almost all such cases, RTI activists have had to go for appeals, with the respective public authority or the commission when a majority of the information should ideally be part of voluntary disclosure.

RTI activist Pankaj Bhatt sought information on th number of Covid-19 deaths in AMCrun hospitals since the outbreak. “The AMC cities confidentiality clauses, but the law regarding birth and deaths says these figures should be updated on the government website periodically,” Bhatt said.

‘Covid’ most searched on Google by Gujaratis

The ‘Year in Searches,’ annual analysis of the searches by Google for Gujarat region revealed that Covid-19 remained on top of the overall searches in 2021. The Gujaratis searched for symptoms of Covid-19, hospital bed availability near them, what is black fungus and optimum oxygen levels among others.