Lifetime RTI ban imposed on whistleblower from Amreli

Lifetime RTI ban imposed on whistleblower from Amreli

‘Cantankerous Approach’ Cited To Negate Right

Ashish.Chauhan@timesgroup.com

Ahmedabad:30.01.2021

The Gujarat information commissioner delivered a serious blow to the Right to Information Act by imposing a lifetime ban on an Amreli man, who has exposed several scams in GSRTC through his applications. In what is probably the first-of-its-kind verdict in the country, the commissioner cited the applicant’s ‘cantankerous approach’ as a reason for taking away his right to know about government affairs -- a fundamental right guaranteed to him under Article 19 of the Constitution.

The commissioner also stated that applicant Manoj Sarpadadia had ‘tried to harass the authorities’.

Sarpadadia, a 46-year-old from Savarkundla, is a bus conductor with Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation (GSRTC). He had been suspended in March 2017 after he allegedly siphoned off money by not issuing tickets to passengers.

He has so far filed 170 RTI applications from 2017 to 2020 regarding alleged irregularities in GSRTC as well as departmental action taken against corrupt employees.

Sarpadadia had on September 12, 2019 filed an RTI plea seeking minutes of GSRTC’s vigilance meeting held in connection with an irregularity practised by an employee.

However, Gujarat information commissioner Ramesh Karia observed that Sarpadadia’s act of filing RTI creates nuisance and disturbance for the state authorities and he has been filing the pleas to take vengeance.

"Commission feels that applicant has a cantankerous approach and he is an applicant who creates constant nuisance and disturbance for the state authorities. This has been reflected in the long lists of his RTI applications where it seems that an employee has been trying to make mockery of his institution by seeking irrelevant information under RTI just because he is aggrieved and wants to take revenge," states an order issued by Karia on December 12, 2020, a copy of which was obtained by Sarpadadia on Monday.

The order also mentions that Sarpadadia has been making mockery of RTI Act. "Sarpadadia has not sought any information which seems relevant with the motto of the act as mentioned in its preamble. The preamble of the Act puts stress on fixing accountability of government officers but this applicant has been acting in such a way that he seems to be putting pressure of government employees," it adds.

Sarpadadia told TOI, “I was suspended wrongfully because I had raised objections against corruption in the ST. However, this gave me time to file RTIs and expose corruption in GSRTC, but they have taken away that right, too.”